Thursday, July 3, 2008

Journal 61: July 2006 Discipline


This ranks right up there with those other hotly debated issues like co-sleeping, breastfeeding, and sleep training. Discipline. To spank or not to spank? When is a time out appropriate? Okay, I’ve tried to distract her from pulling all the CDs out of the shelf over 50 times now. She is going back for another try…what now? And of course, if I am too authoritative, will it stunt her emotionally – yet if I am too permissive will she become a brat?



These questions and many more are scrambling inside my brain. I’ve been thinking about this issue for a long time, but now “thinking” days are over and I have found myself smack dab in the middle of toddler behavior. I even bought Dr. Sears Discipline book about 6 months ago (amidst lots of laughter and snickering from family and friends.) But I was really worried about this. I was the type of kid that took a disapproving look from my mom and ceased the disruptive behavior. Sadie already seems more high spirited than that. I give her the “mommy’s not happy” look and she raises her eyebrows, makes this silly nod with her chin jutted out, and then says something like “Ah-goh-doo-dah”. Could she be saying, “I’m gonna do that?” Oh, please no! How did Seth and I, both basically easy going people create this little spitfire?



With our at home struggles I am much more at ease. At home there is no “audience” for either of us to perform to. If she ends up throwing a major tantrum, it is much easier to ignore without throngs of people watching. I am startled at how many people are just dying to give unsolicited advice about behavior. Although I am not sure why I am surprised – it was the same thing over Sadie’s weight. (Which by the way, she is still under the bottom curve line on the charts – but she is staying on her curve and developing normally). I used to think nothing could ever bother me more than people’s “helpful” comments about how tiny she is. But the comments about discipline really get to me.



For example, every Wednesday, I take her down to the park to hear the band play. There are many older people in lawn chairs and some families. Most usually Sadie stays right with me and plays, dances, or eats her snack. However, last Wednesday night she had a bad case of “ants in the pants” and would not stay still. She actually would not even stay close to me. She has recently discovered the fact that grass is different than black top or cement and so she runs straight for the non-grassy areas whenever she gets the chance. While there was really no traffic in the park, I don’t want her to think that she can step on the pavement without holding my hand…so I spent much of the concert jumping up to retrieve her when the mood hit her to make a run for it. A well meaning lady near us says,



“You need to get a leash or harness for her!”

Stunned I just smiled uncomfortably and said,

“She is quite a handful.”



Now I am not sure how I feel about leashes – I mean, I do use one with the dog, but I also make her eat off the floor and poop in the yard.



Speaking of the dog, Maggie has been a handful – especially since Seth left. Whereas I played the role of nurturing caretaker, Seth was the “alpha dog” in the house. Maggie responded to his commands…mine she sees as suggestions. She hasn’t done anything really wrong yet, but she is overly protective of Sadie and I to the point that she barks and growls at most strangers and every noise she hears. So I took her to the dog trainer for a day long assessment. The trainer was really impressed with what a good natured and smart dog she is (black lab mix) and was able to identify the problem immediately. In Seth’s absence – which Maggie is mourning like the rest of us – she feels that there is no one in control of the house looking out for our safety and well being. So she is doing what she thinks she needs to do in order to be top dog and take care of her family. Oh, that makes me so sad, but at the same time, it is a motivating kick in the pants for me.



It isn’t Maggie’s job or Sadie’s job to take care of us or to have to worry whether or not we will be okay. I have to be so careful that I do not give the impression that I can’t handle this or that I am not in control. And that is so hard, because I do not feel my strength or ability to make it through this.



The trainer said, “You can’t doubt yourself. When you tell her to do something you have to mean it with your words, your body, everything. You have to be certain of yourself.” Okay, I know she is talking about the dog, but we are really talking about everything in my life right now. I am so uncertain. I second guess myself all the time. But when it comes to Sadie, just like with Maggie, I have to be certain of what I am doing. She is going to test the limits and look for the loopholes.



And with all this talk about discipline it should be noted that I am least disciplined with myself. It is something that I have tried to change many times with little success. I continue to work on it as I probably will for the rest of my life. But I can see now where the issues might not be so much what technique or school of thought I am using to modify Sadie's behavior. The key may be in my own level of confidence. Knowing that I can do this and believing that the decisions I have made are for the best could be what needs to happen first – before I can bring order into our home. All of the disarray did not leave with Seth – there is still the work I need to do with myself. Raising her up to be a confident, responsible, loving young woman may be the hardest job I have ever set my hand to.



Now for Sadie’s take on the whole issue: Last night she meticulously scribbled on several pages of Dr. Sears Discipline Book with an ink pen that she took from my purse when I wasn’t looking. It’s going to get harder, isn’t it?

No comments:

Post a Comment