Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Journal 24: August 2005 Solids

I have found that one of the most hotly debated issues of the first six months of a baby life is the question of feeding. The topic is emotionally charged and begins with the decision to breast or bottle feed. It is difficult, if not impossible, to find someone who is ambivalent about the issue. Moms who breastfeed will swear it is the best. Moms who formula feed either adamantly hold that they physically could not do it and seem really regretful and apologetic or they reply with “I chose not to” and then stare defiantly as if to say, “You wanna make something of it?” Sadie and I, through her weigh struggles, have defended the continued breastfeeding on more than one occasion.

The item next up for debate is SOLIDS. Wow! This one makes the capital punishment argument seem tame. Although I have heard repeatedly that you should not put cereal in a bottle, and that introduction of solids does not help babies to sleep longer, I still am surprised at the number of people I know who advocate the practice. I am not judging. Honestly, I do not really care how or when other people choose to feed their babies. However, I don’t particularly care for all of the advice offered up in this department. I think that is because it is usually given as though it IS the gospel truth. I have tried to smile politely, but it does get tiring to be told that you need to give them this or that particular food. I think that may be due to the fact that the issue on the table is food, the very substance that keeps us alive. Criticism about how or what you are feeding your baby is particularly hard to take as it seems to imply that you are failing at one of the most important and most basic aspects of raising a little human being.

I decided to wait to give Sadie any foods until 6 months. I had even read that the American Association of Pediatrics recommended waiting until 6 months to reduce allergies. However, at 4 months everyone questioned us about cereal. Even the doctor said we could start soon. We waited until 5 months. Now that she is coming up on her 6 month birthday, I am feeling incompetent as a mother (not for the first time and probably not the last). Sadie really seems to hate the cereal, both rice and oatmeal. I mixed it with breast milk and even tasted it myself. It certainly wasn’t as horrible as her face would indicate. After two weeks of attempting cereal every other day, tonight I though we would try a mashed banana with some breast milk. I was hopeful. One of the “gospel bits of truth” I had been getting from other mothers is that Sadie will love bananas because they are sweet. Sadie spit and frowned at me like I was crazy. I even had Seth try, but to no avail. She took a little off my finger, but I think that was only because she wanted to chew on my finger.

So I ask myself, “So what if she doesn’t take to solids right now?” And then I reply with, “Everyone else’s baby past and present was taking solids now.” And I think that is what disturbs me the most. Just because other babies got started on solids and did well at 5 to 6 months, doesn’t mean that Sadie has to. My only responsibility is to offer it right now – which I am doing.

I have read so many things that clearly explain that solids should not replace breast milk or formula and that those should remain the bulk of baby’s diet until one year. I have also read that starting solids is not about nutrition as much as it is just learning how to take solids and accepting different textures. This leaves me to wonder why so many people are so anxious to get baby on solid and table food so quickly. It doesn’t sound like there is a medical reason to do so.

Sadie turns 6 months old the 20th of August. I am hoping that we will be able to get some cereal or banana acceptance by that point. At the same time, we are trying to get back on track with nursing now that I am on thyroid medicine and my supply should improve. Sadie gets weighed tomorrow at Mom’s Group. I am holding my breath that she will show some significant gain. OK, I would be pleased with even insignificant gain at this point. Regardless, I am going to have to shut off my ears when a well meaning mother swears that solids are the answer to my problems,

Maybe Sadie just hates cereal and bananas. Maybe she is holding out for pizza and soda pop. Who knows? Just as everything else has been with Sadie, there is no benefit in pushing her; she seems to do things when she is ready.

2 comments:

  1. Hey, Amy! I'm reading & comparing Sadie's milestones with Maggie's - i just proves that every babby is different! Sadie didn't care for solids at first but Maggie loves them! Her favorites are carrots and peas. She started solids 2 weeks ago - just vegetables and we started giving her 1 oz every other day, then 2 oz. every other day and now she has been eating 2 oz. every night for the last 5 days. I almost cried when she had her first big-girl poop - I'm going to really miss the easy breastmilk poopy diapers! LOL I'm stil reading on, but thanks for telling me about your blog! It's nice to read about the same things I'm experiencing through the eyes of another mom - reminds me I'm not crazy! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  2. The breastmilk diapers are so easy compared to the other stuff :) I can't remember if I ended up writing it here or not - but Sadie did finally warm up to avacados. She ate tons of them. So many that a couple of her poops were super bright playdoh green and nearly scared the crap out of me - but the doctor said it was okay!

    ReplyDelete